Skip to main content

MGNREGA: World's largest poverty alleviation programme?


This post is about Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act 2005 (MGNREGA), which aims at providing 100 days of guaranteed employment to anyone who applies for jobs. How successful has it been?

First let’s see what the government official website for NREGA states. Dividing person-days generated per year with the total number of individuals who worked, average days of employment provided per individual was 30.8 days in 2017, 30.72 days in 2016, 32.54 days in 2015, and only 26.72 days in 2014. The NDA led government came into power in 2014 and the Hon’able Prime Minister himself stated that NREGA will only act as a souvenir to the failure of UPA Govt, in 2016.  

Average days of employment provided per household was 45.71 in 2017, 46 in 2016, 48.85 in 2015 and 40.17 in 2014, stated explicitly on the website. One household in India has on an average 4.45 people.

Apparently, this is the new meaning of 100 days of guaranteed employment.

NREGA workers across Jharkhand haven’t got their pay since March 7, their fund transfer orders not been cleared by the centre. One should take note that this is the beginning of the fiscal year when there is no shortage of funds. (TOI)

However in Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala, some NREGA projects have been flourishing. 2,032 farm ponds have been constructed by NREGA workers across 73 Panchayats which have a total capacity of holding 3.72 lakh kilolitres of water. This is an effective mechanism against drought, which Kerala is facing, the worst it has seen in 115 years. (TOI)

Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG) report stated that NREGA had failed for Orissa till 2016, where the per annum income of the households across all districts of the state were Rs 671- Rs 1630. In other words, 4 people can survive through an entire year with Rs 1630 in hand, and that through this income they are rising above poverty levels in India. (Slow claps?)

Even after Rs 47,500 Cr allocation to the rural scheme, 56% wages had been delayed in 2016. This is because the fund transfer has been digitized now. The National Electronic Fund Management System (NEFMS) transfers the wages directly from centre to the labourers’ bank accounts. This step reduces the risk of dilution of funds through middlemen; however it is very chaotic and has often resulted in delayed wages, as we can see.

In 2016-17, liabilities pending from previous years were Rs 13,220 Cr, over the already made expenditure of Rs 45,303 Cr. This was the after-effect of demonetization in the rural India. Increased budget, and increased wage delays. (IndiaSpend)
  
There is a special council for both centre and state in the NREGA act, which serves as a watchdog for MGNREGA and ensures accountability. They are the Centre Employment Guarantee Council (CEGC) and the State Employment Guarantee Council. The term for CEGC is one year, after which it is supposed to be re-appointed. The CEGC was not in action since June 2012 till May 2016, almost four years where MGNREGA was implemented without any accountability (IndianExpress). 

These four years fall under both the UPA Govt as well as the NDA Govt. An inspection of the NREGA Govt website also confirms the same.

However, the current Govt has made many attempts at making NREGA more transparent. The above mentioned NEFMS is one initiative. Geo-tagging all the assets built through MNREGA and there has been an increase in person-days too. However, the person-days generated don’t meet the demand for employment, and electronic fund transfer system leads to many delays.

One summarizes that the current government is on par with the previous one. UPA Govt started MGNREGA, but didn’t implement it with full potential. NDA Govt has brought many new initiatives under the same, but they too have been haphazard. In actual, life for the rural population is just as it had been earlier, one fraught with difficulties and hardships, while governments play their political games compromising the rural interests.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

People's representatives in our democracy are benign

In all the hot debate over rapes and crimes against women in India, we should remember that just after Nirbhaya case in December 2012, a special 3-member commission was set up to recommend amendments to the Criminal Law so as to provide for quicker trial and enhanced punishment for criminals accused of committing sexual assault against women, which can today be googled by the tags “ Verma Commission ”. The commission took the liberty to suggest amendments in the Representation of People’s act 1951 . Let’s analyze what has been done about it 5 years down the line. Suggestion No. 1 was to "eliminate" those representatives with criminal antecedents. however, 34% of MP’s elected in 2014 had criminal charges against them, 21% had serious criminal cases ( ibtimes ). 30% of candidates in the Bihar elections had criminal cases against them, ( TheHindu ). The most recent study by Association of Democratic Reforms (19 April, 2018) has stated that 1580 MP’s/MLA’s have crim...

British Legacy in India

India was called “British India” for almost a 100 years, from 1858 till 1947. Certainly there have been developments in India in the past 70 years; it is undeniable that there are remnants of the British legacy still found in corners of Indian streets. From the khaki colour of the Indian police uniform, to becoming the second largest English speaking nation in the world ( BBC ), though the attribute for this is the exploding Indian population, vestiges of the British Raj can still be found in the people here. The above speculations gain ground when we observe the Indian Constitution and the Indian Penal Code, which still have many laws that came into being during the British Raj, to help the crown gain more and more control over the people. 1. Section 377 - This law states, in informal words, that oral or anal sex is a criminal offense in India . Now this law is open to interpretations, and many a times, magistrates wrongly interpret it as criminalizing homosexuality. This ar...